Custodial Death in India: Causes, Need for Reform

Custodial death, a grave violation of human rights, refers to the demise of an individual while in the custody of law enforcement agencies or correctional facilities. This phenomenon has been a persistent issue in India, raising concerns about the practices and accountability of the police and correctional institutions.

Defining Custodial Death

Custodial death encompasses fatalities that occur in jails, police vehicles, or during medical treatment while the individual is still under custody. These deaths can result from various causes, including excessive use of force, medical neglect, abuse, or even suicide. The Law Commission of India classifies any crime committed by a public servant against a detained or arrested individual as custodial violence.

The State of Custodial Deaths in India

The statistics on custodial deaths in India reveal a troubling trend. Between 2017 and 2022, the number of custodial deaths fluctuated, with the highest being 175 in 2021-2022. States like Gujarat, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, and Bihar reported the highest incidences. The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has recommended monetary relief in numerous cases, highlighting the severity of the issue.

Causes Behind Custodial Deaths

• Absence of Strong Legislation: India lacks specific anti-torture legislation, and custodial violence remains non-criminalized. This legal gap allows officials to evade accountability for their actions.
• Excessive Force: Law enforcement agencies often use excessive force, especially against marginalized communities, to extract confessions or control individuals. This practice not only violates human rights but also leads to severe injuries and deaths.
• Institutional Challenges: The prison system in India suffers from a lack of transparency, overcrowding, and inadequate safety measures. These conditions exacerbate the risk of custodial deaths.
• Medical Neglect: Often, detainees do not receive proper medical attention, leading to deaths from treatable conditions or worsening pre-existing medical issues.
• Psychological Neglect: The mental health of prisoners is frequently overlooked, with no psychiatric support to help them cope with the stress and trauma of imprisonment.
• Lengthy Judicial Processes: The protracted and costly legal processes deter the poor and vulnerable from seeking justice, allowing custodial violence to persist.

Legal Provisions and Protections

• Constitutional Protections: Articles 21 and 22 of the Indian Constitution safeguard the right to life and personal liberty and provide protection against arrest and detention in certain cases. These articles are crucial in ensuring that detainees’ rights are upheld.
• Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC): Section 41 of the CrPC includes safeguards to ensure that arrests and detentions are conducted transparently and with reasonable grounds.
• Indian Penal Code (IPC): Sections 330, 331, and 348 of the IPC address the infliction of injuries to extort confessions, while Sections 302, 304, 304A, and 306 provide punishments for custodial torture and related crimes.
• Indian Evidence Act, 1872: Sections 25 and 26 protect detainees from self-incrimination and ensure that confessions made under police coercion are inadmissible in Court.

The Way Forward

To mitigate custodial deaths, India must implement comprehensive reforms:

• Strengthening Legislation: Enacting anti-torture laws and criminalizing custodial violence are essential steps toward holding officials accountable.
• Improving Transparency: Enhancing transparency in the prison system through regular inspections and independent oversight can help address the systemic issues.
• Training and Accountability: Law enforcement officials should undergo rigorous training on human rights and non-lethal methods of interrogation. Establishing independent bodies to investigate custodial deaths can ensure accountability.
• Medical and Psychological Support: Providing adequate medical care and psychological support to detainees can prevent deaths due to neglect and untreated conditions.
• Judicial Reforms: Expediting judicial processes and making them more accessible to the poor and vulnerable can help in delivering timely justice and deterring custodial violence.

Conclusion

Custodial deaths are a blot on India’s human rights record, reflecting systemic failures in law enforcement and correctional practices. Addressing this issue requires a multifaceted approach, encompassing legal reforms, improved transparency, better training for officials, and comprehensive medical and psychological support for detainees. Only through concerted efforts can India hope to eradicate the scourge of custodial deaths and uphold the Fundamental rights of all its citizens.

Sharing is caring!