Farm Loan Waiver in India: A Report by NABARD

 

Farm loan waiver UPSC: Relevance

• GS 3: Issues related to direct and indirect farm subsidies

 

Loan waiver in India: Context

• Recently, National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (NABARD) and Bharat Krishak Samaj has jointly released a report on recent farm loan waivers by the three state governments— Punjab, Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra.

NABARD report on loan waiver: Key findings

• Borrowing by states: The study revealed that an average farmer of Punjab borrows four times more money than those in Uttar Pradesh (UP) and over five times more money than those in Maharashtra.
  • The study also revealed that a marginal farmer in Punjab borrows Rs 3.4 lakh annually, as compared to Rs 84,000 and Rs 62,000 in UP and Maharashtra, respectively.
  • A marginal farmer is one who has the landholding of <1 ha.
  • According to the report, more than 40 per cent of the “very highly” distressed farmers in these states did not receive any farm loan waiver (FLW) benefits.
  • Among the three states, Punjab farmers borrowed the largest amounts per farmer category and their dependence on non-institutional sources was also the highest across all farmer categories.
  • The average amount of loan taken from institutions increased with the landholding size.

 

• Loan waiver promoted wilful defaults: The study also revealed that the waivers increased the chances of wilful defaults by farmers and the waiver pushed even the honest farmers to default on agricultural loans.
• Institutional borrowings: Among the three states, the proportion of farmers of Punjab borrowing from the institutional sources were more than those in UP and Maharashtra.
• Interest rates: The interest rates on non-institutional loans were found to be much more than the institutional loans.
• Default on institutional loans: The possibility of default was higher on institutional loans than on non-institutional loan.
• Kisan Credit card: The diversion of KCC (Kisan Credit Card) funds for non-agricultural use was highest in the case of Punjab and lowest in the case of UP.
  • The study also revealed that for an average farmer diversion of funds is inevitable and critical for survival.
• Waiver and political connections: During the election campaigns, political parties race to become the first to promise a waiver on agricultural loans.
  • Moreover, these waivers are positioned as a ‘ram-baan’ solution to any distress faced by Indian farmers.
  • The study has, however, revealed that despite several successive governments implementing these loan waivers, the farmer distress has become more acute, let alone reducing it.
• Effect on state finances: The study revealed that loan waivers in Punjab has affected the expenditure on other departments.
  • In Punjab, both developmental expenditure and capital outlay (as a percentage of GSDP) fell due to outstanding liabilities and market borrowings.
• Reasons of farmer suicides: The study highlighted that due to restrictions imposed by COVID-19, in all the three states, successive crop loss, indebtedness and excessive reliance on agricultural income together were the prime causes of farmer suicides.

 

 

Loan waiver as a solution

• Loan waiver is not an efficient way to alleviate farmer distress and it is only a short-term solution after which farmers will go back to taking loans.
• The waivers worsened the credit discipline among the farmers in the medium and long run.
• Farm loan waivers were designed as a reaction to acute agrarian distress and to ensure the continuity of future credit but it has evolved to emerge as a political tool that is strategically used by political parties to influence rural voters.
• The design of loan waivers is such that a large section of the people whose loan should have been waived were unable to benefit from the process.

 

Read current affairs for UPSC

Water issue in India: India to Try New Groundwater Recharge Methods	Declining Nitrogen Levels in Nitrogen Rich World	Green Hydrogen Policy | Green Ammonia Policy	‘Smart Cities, Smart Urbanization’ Conference 2022
Semicon India 2022 Conference	Extreme Poverty Reduced in India, As Per the New World Bank Report	Indo-Finnish Virtual Network Centre on Quantum Computing	Seaweed Farming in India: India’s First Seaweed Park in Tamil Nadu
Tiger Deaths, Tiger Conservation status and Protection Measures in India	e-DAR Portal	Increasing Women on the e-Shram Portal	Prime Minister’s Award for Excellence in Public Administration: UDAN Scheme Selected for the Award
ICDS Scheme: Maharashtra Develops Migration Tracking System	Singapore International Water Week (SIWW) 2022 | Water Convention 2022	Providing Credit Card to MSME Entrepreneurs	‘Tree City of the World’ Tag